As Easter approaches, the Peanut Butter Egg is a popular and beloved confection. And while peanut butter is the most popular flavor, there are several variations of these made-from-scratch sweet treats, including coconut and buttercream. You can find these delicious creations throughout Cumberland Valley in the weeks leading up to Easter.

Oak Grove Farms Easter EggsOak Grove Farms

846 Fisher Rd., Mechanicsburg; 717-766-2216

Varieties include peanut butter, peanut butter fluff, buttercream, coconut cream, coconut pecan, raspberry, and mint. Most varieties are available in milk chocolate or dark chocolate. $1.99 each, $10.99/per half dozen; $19.99/per dozen. Plus, there is an incredible variety of chocolate Easter candies, pretzel wheels, chocolate-covered peeps, and hard candies.

Hollabaugh Bros.

545 Carlisle Rd., Biglerville; 717-677-8412

Peanut butter, coconut. $12/per half dozen; $22/per dozen. Click here to pre-order by March 25. Don't miss out on their peanut butter egg milkshake. Made with Mr. G's homemade chocolate peanut butter ice cream and topped with whipped cream and one of their peanut butter eggs, this delightful treat is back for a limited time.

Whimsical PoppyThe Whimsical Poppy

417 N. Baltimore Ave., Mt. Holly Springs; 717-486-5202

Peanut butter, coconut cream, buttercream, caramel with sea salt, cherry, orange, and maple walnut eggs from Lloyd's Chocolates are available at The Whimsical Poppy. 

New Cumberland River Rescue

New Cumberland River Rescue is selling peanut butter and coconut Easter eggs for $1.50 an egg. You can purchase eggs at Weist Hardware (1512 Bridge Street), First Church of God in New Cumberland (4th and Reno Ave), or Highland Gardens (423 S 18th St, Camp Hill), or contact NCRR via email at or phone at (717) 774-7555.