As Easter approaches, the Peanut Butter Egg is a popular and beloved confection. And while peanut butter is the most popular flavor, there are several variations of these made-from-scratch sweet treats, including coconut and buttercream. You can find these delicious creations throughout Cumberland Valley in the weeks leading up to Easter. More locations will be added as information becomes available.
Oak Grove Farms
846 Fisher Rd., Mechanicsburg; 717-766-2216
Varieties include peanut butter, peanut butter fluff, coconut cream, butter cream, krispy, maple, mint, peaches & cream, and raspberry. $1.99/each; $10.99/half-dozen, $19.99/dozen. Plus, you'll find an incredible variety of other Easter sweet treats.
Bella Sicilia Bakery
79 Erford Rd., Camp Hill
Check out the large and customized Easter Eggs from Bella Sicilia, available in white chocolate, milk chocolate, or dark chocolate. A lucky few will receive an egg that contains either a $20, $50, or $100 gift card to the bakery. These will be pre-ordered only. To order, call or text 223-388-9913.
Kings Gap General Store
1155 Pine Rd., Carlisle, 717-486-3441
Orders can be placed starting March 5 and pick up starts on March 8. Flavors: Peanut Butter, Coconut, and Teaberry. Dark or Milk Chocolate. $14/dozen. Eggs must be ordered by the dozen. Flavors can be mixed.
The Java Junky
Located inside the Carlisle Country Market, 1146 Holly Pike, Carlisle
Peanut butter, coconut cream, and butter cream are available in dark, milk, and white chocolate. Coming soon: raspberry cream, orange cream, cherry cream, and maple. Stop by the Java Junky to pre-order. Open Friday 7 am to 4 pm and Saturday 7 am to 2 pm. $1.75/each or $19.25/dozen.
More locations will be added as information becomes available.
Pennsylvania Bakery
1713 Market St., Camp Hill
Peanut Butter Eggs & Coconut Cream Eggs are back, along with NEW Peeps Cream Pie & Peanut Butter Egg Pie, Lemon Mousse Pyramids, & Peeps Individual Cheesecakes! Order online.
Brew Crumberland's Best
1903 Bridge St., New Cumberland
The BCB holiday egg trio is back, featuring one Inside-Out Egg (chocolate filling coated in Peanut Butter), one Peanut Butter Egg (Peanut Butter filling coated in Chocolate), and one Coconut Egg (Coconut filling coated in Chocolate).
