Cheesesteaks are a staple in Pennsylvania’s food scene, and Cumberland Valley is the ideal place to find authentic, high-quality sandwiches. Here are the restaurants that make the best cheesesteaks in the Valley.
Philadelphia Steak & Hoagies
Located in Camp Hill, Philadelphia Steak & Hoagies is dedicated to providing customers with the authentic Philly flavor and experience. Served on a South Philly Italian roll with steak cut fresh every morning, this hoagie will leave you wanting seconds. Go with the original that comes with cheese wiz or customize it to fit your palate. Served with your choice of onion and hot or sweet pepper. This sandwich is the real deal.
Amici’s Million Dollar Cheesesteak
Who would’ve thought you could get a million-dollar experience right here on the Carlisle Pike in Mechanicsburg? Amici’s certainly thinks you can with their million-dollar cheesesteak. This sandwich is made with grilled onions and Cooper cheese on a seeded roll. Their recipe was inspired by a trip to Angelo’s in Philly and has since lived up to its name. The massive portions will have you enjoying this creation for days to come.
The Cheesesteak Guy
Looking for a twist on this Pennsylvania staple? The Cheesesteak Guy is the place to go! Go with the classic route and customize a traditional cheesesteak with your choice of meat, cheese, and roll type. If you’re feeling adventurous, choose from a selection of specialty sandwiches. Test out the Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak, Chicken Cordon Bleu Cheesesteak, or Cacio e Pepe, which features shaved ribeye, black pepper, roasted garlic, and onions with a Cooper White cheese sauce. With so many options, you’ll have to keep coming back to try them all!
Home Slice at Walden
With a wide variety of food options to choose from, this pizzeria has nailed down the art of the cheesesteak. Served on a fresh, 12-inch roll with a side of homemade chips and a pickle, this is a deal worth revisiting again and again. Their classic cheesesteak comes with thinly sliced prime rib, caramelized onions, Cooper Sharp cheese, and mayo on a toasted roll. Experiment with other items on their menu, such as the chicken cheesesteak or the special cheesesteak, which comes with the addition of pepperoni, mushrooms, and peppers. No matter what you choose, you cannot go wrong!
South Side Deli
Southside Deli in Carlisle will take your cheesesteak game to the next level. Choose from more than 50 toppings and condiments to make your creation truly one of a kind. Their pastrami cheesesteak offers a unique twist on the classic, featuring grilled pastrami, grilled red onion, roasted red pepper, mayo, and Cooper Sharp cheese. Gluten-free rolls are available, so everyone can enjoy this one-of-a-kind experience.
With all these great restaurants serving authentic cheesesteaks, there are plenty of options to get a taste of Philly, right here in Cumberland Valley! Now all you have to decide is which one you want to try first!
