Plenty of places in Cumberland Valley spark passion among locals and visitors. Today, these strong opinions are often expressed on social media. To harness the friendly debates in our comment section, we created “The Cumberlands: The Cumberland Valley People’s Extremely Strong Opinions Awards.” Our followers nominated and voted for their favorite business or location in Cumberland Valley across a variety of categories.
Check out the winners and plan a weekend getaway with stops to experience these Cumberland Valley favorites.
The Best Fry Situation: One13 Social
French fries are a go-to side at any restaurant. A good fry can elevate a dish, and a bad one can tank it. Luckily, One13 Social has mastered the art of the french fry. Perfectly seasoned, crispy, and fluffy, this side will leave you wanting more.
#1 Place You’d Defend Like a Sports Team: Hamilton Restaurant
The Hamilton has been a staple in the Downtown Carlisle community since 1938. Serving the legendary “Hot-Chee Dog,” this hot dog is piled high with cheese, chili, mustard, and diced onion. Trying this menu item at the iconic restaurant is a must if you want to feel like a local in Carlisle.
Most Emotionally Supportive Coffee Shop: Nour
If you’re looking for good vibes and a boost of caffeine to start your day, look no further than Nour in Camp Hill. This coffee shop’s mission is to train, employ, and empower neurodivergent and neurotypical individuals while delivering the highest quality coffee, tea, and food. Not only will you be served a delicious treat, but you will also be greeted with a big smile from their friendly staff.
Top Grass Sitting Experience: Ever Grain Brewing Co.
There’s no better feeling than sitting outside with an ice-cold beer in your hand. Luckily, Ever Grain Brewing Co. provides the perfect opportunity for you to do so. Relax at a picnic table or in Adirondack chairs and enjoy a fresh brew.
Best Place to Pretend You’re in a Hallmark Movie: Children's Lake
Boiling Springs perfectly captures the small-town feel found in Hallmark movies. Located in the heart of Boiling Springs in Children’s Lake. Take a stroll around “Lover’s Walk” and view the picturesque lake, gazebo, historical buildings, and wildlife. This is the perfect romantic spot to feel like you’re in a movie.
Top Restaurant to Pretend You’re in a Different Country: Hellenic Kouzina Greek Cafe
Greek food consistently ranks among the top international cuisines in the world. For an authentic experience, visit Hellenic Kouzina in Mechanicsburg. Serving fresh, Mediterranean dishes, eating here will transport your taste buds to Athens.
Best Spot to Accidentally Spend $200: West Shore Farmers Market
The West Shore Farmers Market is a dangerous place if you’re on a budget. From produce to fresh meat, bakeries, and food to-go, there are plenty of options to draw your attention. With all the high-quality food available, keep a close eye on your receipts!
Best Place to Say “This Counts as Exercise”: Pole Steeple
Want a break from the gym and take in picture-perfect views of Cumberland Valley? The Pole Steeple trail in Michaux State Forest is the best place to say “this counts as exercise.” This short, steep climb to the top of Piney Mountain takes you to a scenic overlook, making it hard for you to hit the treadmill again!
Bar You’re Most Likely to Run into Your Entire High School: Gingerbread Man
Want to run back old memories with familiar faces? The Gingerbread Man in Carlisle is the place to go. This bar is a local favorite and is bound to reconnect you with high school friends.
Perfect Place to Accidentally Take 47 Sunset Photos: Silver Side Café & Creamery
The sunsets in Cumberland Valley are truly stunning, especially at Silver Side Café & Creamery. Sit on their patio, ice cream in hand, and enjoy the beautiful pastel-painted skies in the evening. Make sure your phone has enough storage because your camera roll will fill up quickly!
Downtown with the Most “Main Character Energy”: Downtown Carlisle
From High Street to Hanover and everything in between, Downtown Carlisle is the place to be in Cumberland Valley. Stop into boutiques, cafes, restaurants, and artisan shops in this very walkable downtown.
Most Dangerous Little Treat: Dough N Joe
Serving fresh, homemade donuts, Dough N Joe will satisfy your sweet tooth. From traditional flavors like glazed and Boston Crème to unique flavors like red velvet and cherry crumb, there is no way you can pick just one, making this the most dangerous little treat in the Valley.
It's no wonder why these places in Cumberland Valley spark so much passion among locals and visitors. Next time you’re visiting, try one of these places and see for yourself why they’re so popular.
